Message 174 of 289

Balzac and Catherine ... de'Medici, That Is

Balzac wrote a book on the history of Catherine de'Medici. And lucky us, it is translated into English, (whew, thank Buddha, because I don't think my Spanish-saturated mind is up to plowing through 19th century French), and even luckier us, it is available FREE, yes, my friends, FREE, simply for the downloading at Project Gutenberg. Here: view link

In his introduction, Balzac says:

for whoever studies modern history to its depths, it is plain that historians are privileged liars, who lend their pen to popular beliefs precisely as the newspapers of the day, or most of them, express the opinions of their readers.

Historians as 'Privileged liars'. Quite a condemnation, don't you think? But true?

Well, a great deal of the Introduction is dedicated to this type of rant, and I must admit I swear I have read it all before in the various rants and comments here on Eons. Ahhh, plus ça change, plus c'est la même chose, n'cest pas?

So, dear ones, who's up for reading this tome?
MartiInMexico's profile
I tried to read it , I really did . Who would have thought that Balzac was such a closed-minded royalist and anti-Protestant ? How very true that so much of history is lies , either deliberate , or simply mis-informed . Mark twain said " The very ink with which history is written is fluid prejudice " .

over 2 years ago
The reference to Salomon de Caux is very interesting . We are taught in school that James Watt invented the steam engine . De Caux seems to have done it about 150 years before Watt , yet gets no credit today . Of course Hero of Alexandria invented a steam engine about 2000 years before De Caux , but his was incapable of doing any real work .

over 2 years ago
I am finding Balzac's pro Catholic Church, anti-Calvanists stance very interesting, having just read that long piece on the Huguenot history, whose modern day author took every opportunity to jab the Catholic Church.
MartiInMexico's profile

over 2 years ago
It is curious how that brand of conservatism in France lumped Catholicism together with royality

I would be interested in reading this work which I was not familiar with
Raouf's profile

over 2 years ago
Here's the link, in case it got buried in my original post . view link
MartiInMexico's profile

over 2 years ago
Probably I am prejudiced because my Huguenot ancestors barely missed being slaughtered for daring to suggest that the corrupt Catholic Church needed to be reformed , but I find it very difficult to summon up much sympathy or support for a religious bureaucracy which was so rotten to its core that it advocated killing in the most painful ways possible anyone who challenged its privileged position .

over 2 years ago
I am really far into this book, and it is absolutely fascinating, once you get past his initial ranting. He is a wonderful writer and this is a great translation. If you have an interest at all in this period, I urge you to read this.

And now I am going to have to read some of Balzac's other work. Darn. One thing leads to another to another to another and the next thing you know, you are saying to your embalmers, 'Wait. Wait. I just have one more chapter to go in this book.'
MartiInMexico's profile

over 2 years ago
Corrupt? The main point of difference with the Church of their time was theological, not practical.
LifeLoveLaughter's profile

over 2 years ago
I will have to read this, Like others I have attempted reading Balzac in the past but it just wasn't in the cards at the time.
I have a strange sense of humor at times and couldn't help but notice the Tags that appear at the site. We go from the Florence twin, to Italian leather purses, to Things to do near D.C. One could probably write a novel just based on that chain! Dan Brown?
cls6926's profile

over 2 years ago
It is a little slow in the beginning, but persevere. It gets really really interesting about 30 pages in or so, after he gets done ranting about the politics in general, and gets into telling the story.
MartiInMexico's profile

over 2 years ago

Eons Picks

Visit Eons-Only Specials
For a limited time, get FREE SmartSound Earbuds on purchases of $100+! Use the code “EONSBUDS” at checkout.

Eons Rewards Club
Great shopping deals & savings for Eons Members!

Save on Eons Games
Eons Downloadable Games. Now just $6.99!

Read Member Blogs
Eons has great blogs—read the latest from members or start yours!